The Advantages of Using Polarized 3D Technology for Surgeries
Stereoscopic or 3D film has existed since the early 1900s, however we’re most familiar with its rise to fame in the early 2000s due to its widespread use in movie theatres. Recently, 3D technology has made its way into the medical field, from da Vinci robotic surgery to 3D endoscopy. With the advantages that 3D surgery brings, we’re likely to see much growth in this area.
Humans are quite good at detecting depth on 2D images. We use a variety of ‘techniques’ to sense depth, be it from relative sizes of objects, motion, textures, lighting and/or focus. When watching a movie, even though it’s in 2D you still know exactly where everything is in relation to each other.
But as you probably find when you try walking around with one eye closed, your depth perception, although enough to survive with, is not very accurate. You may find that you misjudge the height of a staircase and trip a little, or you try to catch a ball only to realise you missed it by a few centimetres.
Humans can judge depth in 2D, but they cannot judge depth accurately. And that is why 3D technology is useful in surgeries where accuracy is vital. Stereoscopic surgery seems to be preferred by many doctors, as it allows a sense of depth that cannot be felt with 2D images. This is important in surgery, as injuries may occur to the patient if instruments are not placed in precisely the right position.
3D Technology in Surgery
In order to perceive images in 3D, display systems must mimic the way our own eyes perceive 3D. If you hold your hand in front of your face and close your left eye, you’ll notice that your hand will appear to the left of your vision. And if you close your right eye, it will appear to the right hand side of your vision. Yet when both eyes are open, our hand appears directly in the middle of your vision. Our brains receive two different images, one through each eye, and process the images into one 3D image. In doing so, our brain is able to sense the depth of objects in front of us.
We can mimic this by recording images from two cameras that are next to each other. A display device then ensures that one image is only visible to the left eye, while the other image is visible only to the right. In this way, our brains are able to give us a stereoscopic sense of depth.
There are several ways of creating 3D images on monitors and TVs. These days the most common way is to use either polarized 3D – which is commonly found in movie theatres - or active shutter 3D – which is commonly found in TVs. For surgeries, polarized 3D is the preferred technology. But why? To answer that, you need to understand how each technology works.
How Polarized 3D Works
Polarized 3D technology displays images on a single screen, but uses a polarizer on both the monitor and the glasses, to create two different images for each eye. This is the technology adopted by our own CuratOR EX3220-3D and EX2620-3D surgical monitors. It has many advantages and is cost effective.
Polarized 3D technology works by passing light through a circular polarizer, making the light twist in either a clockwise or anticlockwise direction. On the glasses, the left lens will have a clockwise-polarizer, and the right lens will have an anti-clockwise polarizer. This means that the left lens will absorb clockwise-twisted light, and reflect anti-clockwise-twisted light. On the monitor, the clockwise and anti-clockwise circular polarizers are arranged in strips, so that one set of strips will be visible by the left eye, and the other set of strips will be visible to the right.
To add video to this equation, you need two video sources taken from slightly different perspectives. The display device will arrange the image onto the screen so that the left camera’s video is displayed underneath the clockwise polarizers, whereas the right camera’s video is displayed underneath the anti-clockwise polarizer.
How Active Shutter 3D Works
The active shutter 3D technique creates 3D images by quickly switching between the left and right camera feeds while blocking the left lens when the right image is shown, and blocking the right lens when the left image is shown.
For each video frame, the monitor quickly changes from the left to the right camera feed. This means that for example, if a monitor typically displays one frame every second, a 3D monitor will have to display two frames every second – first the left frame and then the right frame. In order to separate these frames so that your left eye only sees the left image and vice versa, the glasses blacken the opposite lens in time with the switching on-screen. They do this by applying electricity to the liquid crystal lens of the glasses, which causes them to become opaque. As the left image displays on screen, the right lens blackens, and as the right image displays on screen, the left lens blackens.
As you can see here, as the left image displays on screen, the right lens becomes opaque, and vice versa.
Why Polarized 3D Is Used in Surgery
The biggest reason that polarized 3D is preferred in surgeries is due to its safety and reliability. Because the polarization process does not require electricity, the glasses worn by the doctor do not require batteries like active shutter technology. This is vital in potentially long surgeries as batteries may fail halfway through, proving detrimental to the patient. Furthermore active shutter glasses often have ‘crosstalk’ where the synchronization of the display and the glasses becomes skewed, and the left image may leak into the right lens and vice versa. As polarized 3D glasses are static and do not require electricity, there is no possibility of the image becoming skewed – making polarized 3D more reliable. Furthermore, the lack of electrical components in polarized 3D displays makes production cheaper.
Another advantage of polarized 3D is that there is no risk of flicker. Due to the rapid switching of images in active shutter technology, users often notice flicker which can cause headaches and discomfort. Polarized 3D technology does not carry this risk. Furthermore polarized 3D allows for brighter images than active shutter.
However in order to create 3D images, some small disadvantages arise when compared to 2D. Polarized 3D technology displays images that are not whole, but rather divided into strips, which reduces the image quality compared to a 2D image. And active shutter can only show each frame for half the intended time that a 2D video would display. The other disadvantage is that many users find that they feel nauseous or gain a headache after prolonged use, due to the misalignment of the camera. Products like the CuratOR EX3220-3D have measures against this – and allow you to adjust the parallax of images to suit your eyes.
Ultimately the advantages of 3D technology – especially polarized 3D technology – outweigh the disadvantages, allowing doctors to safely see surgical images with a sense of depth.
The advantages and disadvantages are summarized below.
|Polarized 3D||Active Shutter 3D|
3D Technology is entering the medical market in leaps and bounds, and is preferred by many doctors due to the increased depth perception. It is still a growing technology, likely with many improvements to come. Polarized 3D technology is preferred in surgeries as it is safer and more reliable than active shutter, has brighter images and is cheaper to produce.